Book Review: The Wife and the Widow

Set against the backdrop of an eerie island town in the dead of winter, The Wife and The Widow is an unsettling thriller told from two perspectives: Kate, a widow whose grief is compounded by what she learns about her dead husband’s secret life; and Abby, an island local whose world is turned upside when she’s forced to confront the evidence of her husband’s guilt. But nothing on this island is quite as it seems, and only when these women come together can they discover the whole story about the men in their lives. Brilliant and beguiling, The Wife and The Widow takes you to a cliff edge and asks the question: how well do we really know the people we love?

What would you sacrifice to protect someone you love?

The plot of “The Wife and the Widow” is reminiscent of Alex Michaelides’ The Silent Patient, the latter being one of the most awarded and talked-about thrillers of 2019. Novels of this caliber are truly deserving of praise greatly attributed to the authors’ intelligent manipulation of multiple timelines and dual perspectives. The sheer likability of this novel is not the story itself but the way White circumvented the multiple timelines, setting the pace for the big reveal. The result is a brilliant and staggering thriller piece that will leave you breathless afterward.  

The story revolves around the novel’s two female characters, Abby Gilpin and Kate Keddie-the wife and the widow, respectively.  Kate and her daughter, Mia, were supposed to surprise Kate’s husband, John, at the airport from his two-week conference in London for a palliative care research colloquium; but he didn’t arrive as scheduled. Kate soon learns that her husband lied about the conference and so many other things: dark secrets connecting her husband to a tragedy that took place in Belport Island.  What Kate discovers as she sets foot in their holiday home in Belport, starts to unsettle her usual passive demeanor, prompts her to reflect on how well she knew her husband urging her to seek for answers to questions that would reveal so many hidden truths. As Kate learns more about her husband’s past, she knew she will stop at nothing until she finds out what truly happened, even to risk her life for it.

Abby Gilpin’s seemingly normal life changed drastically when her husband confessed to a crime that was the biggest thing to happen in Belport Island in a long time.  Abby soon learns to face the truth about what her husband did and what she decides after that is tethered to the most basic of all maternal instincts: a mother’s protective nature.

Both wives were lied to.  Both husbands were not who they appear to be.  The hunt is on but are they prepared to handle the truth?

This is a clever and brilliantly written book, far better than what I expected.  In terms of plot, “The Wife and the Widow” sits on a high ground due to the complexity of its narrative structure. But the book’s value lies within White’s depiction of the roles mother play in defending and protecting their children even in the most afflicting of circumstances.  The moral problems explored in the book left me with an emotional discomfort that makes me question how far would I go to protect my children. Would the fear of moral ramifications even deter me from making unethical decisions to defend my family? White wishes to implore his readers to think about the implications of every action portrayed in his book.  I just couldn’t help but gush how thought-provoking this novel is. I don’t think I have ever devoured a book as unputdownable as this in a long time and my final verdict is that every reader must learn from stories like this because it may not be far from reality.

Rating: 5 out of 5.

Author: Christian White

Genre: Mystery Thriller / Crime Fiction

Length: 352 pages

Publisher: January 21st 2020 by Minotaur Books

ISBN-10: 1250194377

ISBN-13: 9781250194374